Maybe if I didn't own a previous Columbia Coat to compare it to, I would of rated it higher. I bought this to replace my 30 year old Columbia Double Whammy 3 in 1 that was Large. I wanted a larger size as I put on a little bit of weight. The Large size still fit, but I wanted it a bit loose. So I ordered the XL. It's not much different than my old Columbia. There are no inner chest pockets! Description said 1 chest pocket, and there is one, on the outside and its pretty small. It would of been nice to know it's on the outside. The elastic cuffs are too big. If you don't have gloves with cuffs, cold air WILL enter there. I loved the Columbia Whammy! Not only elastic but also velcro on the cuffs. Gloves in or out, it didn't matter. They fit anything. The hood is big and there's no adjustment tab on the back of the hood. So if I pull on the cords to keep it on my head in the wind, it covers my eyes, poor design. There are no vents of any type under the arms. I didn't expect zippers like my old coat, but at least some small eyelets. I bought it because. 1) I needed a new coat and I HAD great luck with Columbia. 2) I wanted a warm coat just like my old Columbia. All the reviews and news of the new technology made this sound like the coat to get. This isn't as warm. Don't get me wrong, it's warm. But won't do the -1

Columbia really should give customers a way to filter products based on fit. Active Fit fit is terrible-- constricting, restrictive, uncomfortable.

Hey I got my coat earlier then expected and it fit lick a glove.

Thicker and puffier than I was looking for. Not as low profile as my other jackets so hopefully I notice a difference in warmth.

The coziest, warmest, most practical jacket I've ever own.